BY MARK REYNOLDS | MREYNOLDS@TCNEWSPAPERS.COM
Developer Michael Barnett, 43, of Hopewell Junction has been indicted
for his involvement in the Vineyard Commons senior housing project in Highland.
From the start, the luxury rental project
became mired in controversy and debt to the point where the federal Housing and
Urban Development agency, who insured the loan, eventually auctioned off the
mortgage in August 2012 to the True North Management Group, resulting in a $27
million loss. They in turn sued to foreclose on Vineyard Commons Holdings LLC
(in wife Denise Barnett’s name) on Nov.16, 2012, resulting in the Barnett’s
filing for Chapter 7 bankruptcy two weeks later on Nov. 30, 2012, claiming they
owed creditors more than $24 million.
United
States Attorney Preet Bharara signed a 31 count indictment against Michael
Barnett, charging him with Conspiracy, Wire Fraud, Mail Fraud, False Statements
on Loan and Credit Application, Engaging in Monetary Transactions in Property
Derived from Specified Unlawful Activity and for False Statements. Barnett also
helped plan and develop two additional projects in the area, named in the
indictment as ‘Future Projects.”
A timeline of the Conspiracy charges is documented
in the indictment. In 2009 Barnett hired a General Contractor (unnamed) for the
project, who in turn sub-contracted a framing company (also unnamed)
responsible for framing and rough carpentry. A private lender [‘Mortgagor’] in
Washington D.C. provided the financing, a $46 million loan, which was insured
by the Federal Housing Administration [FHA] of the department of Housing and
Urban Development [HUD]. The indictment states that Barnett “used his position
as the developer of Vineyard Commons and the Future Projects to enrich himself
by, among other means, persuading contractors and subcontractors to provide him
with kickbacks and to invest money in Vineyard Commons and the Future
Projects.” The indictment states that Barnett provided the Mortgagor with false
and inflated invoices so the company would provide him with HUD-insured funds.
From
2008 to 2010 the General Contractor and sub-contractors did invest in Vineyard
Commons, in part, because Barnett led them to believe they would be hired for
work at Vineyard Commons and possibly for future projects, according to the
indictment.
The
indictment reveals that in 2009 Barnett solicited sub-contractors at Vineyard
Commons to provide their labor and materials to construct a pool house at his
home residence. Some agreed to do so and would either absorb the cost or
falsely build the costs into those related to Vineyard Commons or on future
projects. Again this was based on the premise that working at Barnett’s home
would mean they would work on his other projects.
On
Jan 19, 2009 the Framer furnished the General Contractor with a Final Bid for
labor and materials for the Vineyard Commons project but by April 2009 the two
agreed to provide this at a greater amount than the Final Bid, which was called
the Contract Price. The indictment states that Barnett, the Framer and the
General Contractor “intended that the difference between the Final Bid and the
Contract Price (called Contract Excess) would be returned to Barnett as a
kickback.” The following month the General Contractor agreed to provide Barnett
with a $1 million letter of credit and in return Barnett “informally pledged”
the Contract Excess to the Contractor as collateral. In June 2009 Barnett also
obtained a letter of credit from the Framer in the amount of $650,000 in order
to secure the HUD/FHA insured financing from the Mortgagor; promising the
contract excess to the Framer as collateral.
On
July 2, 2009 Barnett and others supplied HUD with the contractor’s and or
Mortgagor cost breakdown. This included the Framer’s estimate, which exceeded
his actual price for labor and materials by approximately the Contract Excess.
The indictment states that from July 2009 to
January 2012 the General Contractor submitted his requisitions on HUD forms to
the Mortgagor, which eventually were sent to HUD. The General Contractor
certified that the information on the forms was true and accurate, which
resulted in the Mortgagor disbursing HUD-insured funds each month on the basis
of the requisitions. For this, Barnett was charged with making False Statements
in the months of January, February and March of 2010.
The indictment highlighted the money trail
surrounding Barnett and Vineyard Commons. On January 15, 2010 the Framer sent
Barnett a check for $200,000 from the Contract Excess via Michigan to New York
to a company Barnett controlled. This allowed Barnett to make a partial payment
on his obligation to the General Contractor. This allegedly was done on Jan.
29, 2010 and resulted in the mail fraud charge.
The indictment also charges Barnett with Wire
Fraud, stating that he obtained “money and property by means of false and
fraudulent pretenses, representations and promises” through wire transmissions
and faxes.
The indictment notes that Barnett “willfully
and knowingly” made false statements on loan and credit applications in order
to influence the action of the Federal Housing Administration. There are 13
instances listed in the indictment, from September 2009 through March 2010,
when Barnett allegedly listed false and inflated dollar amounts in invoices so
the Mortgagor “would disburse funds to which Barnett, the General Contractor
and the Vineyard Commons were not entitled.”
According to the indictment, Barnett will
have to forfeit “all property, real and personal that constitutes or is derived
from proceeds traceable to the commission of the offense charged in Count One
[Conspiracy] of this indictment.” This includes 10 Wintergreen Place in
Hopewell Junction. If any property cannot be located because Barnett failed to
mention it, or it has been substantially dimished in value, been sold or
transferred to a third party, has been comingled with other property which
cannot be subdivided off without difficulty or has been placed beyond the
jurisdiction of the court, then his property at 6 Heather Court in Fishkill
will be forfeited.
Barnett
could not be reached for comment for this article.